I like doing quests for Alexander and Pete, because I think they give me the most items that I can use to restock my shops. Carl is also great for selling my inventory. I have only been on a couple of quests for the Oracle, so I don't have enough data to decide how I feel about her.
With Maleria, I often find that the items she asks for are too expensive, and the rewards are not worth it. Of course this depends on the price of the items. I still do her quests, because I am grinding for achievements right now. I have a friend who says Quintin often asks for items that are too expensive for the rewards. I was wondering what experiences other players have had with quests.
[Kiss=Pamiilaq] "Of course, they say every atom in our bodies was once a star." - Vincent
I like Quentin, Wizard, and Alexander the most. Quentin sometimes gives out mage amulets, which you can turn into the Mage for a chance at a tome (stat booster). WIzard gives wizard tokens, which are useful for token shop, blackheart hollow, vending, and more. And Alexander gives great items to re-sell :).
🌑🌒🌓🌔🌕🌖🌗🌘🌑
to the surprise of no one, my favs are wizard, sagittarius, and quentin lol. while wizard is obvious for the tokens, honestly i just like sagittarius and quentin as npcs :'D quentin in particular has always been my fav here, so i always make sure to do their quests, even if i don't always get good stuff |D i just like visiting them!
my favorite for quests is at the moment, probably the library. you rarely get enough sP to cover the purchase of the quest item, but the reward items are generally always rare or super rare and i tend to get plushies i didn't have and some worthwhile stuff for my shop. plus, i love reading, so it is fun to go get books for his quests. i also love quentin, because they're the graveyard spoopy npc who of course deserves all the love. the reward items aren't usually super worthwhile unless you get mage amulets, but i love finding new holiday items i didn't know about and i just love seeing their character. :D
I love Saggi & The Wizard. I save them for last. lol I usually do Quen first because she rarely gives me anything!
[tot=Sarki]
My favorite is Alexander, I like getting items and I feel like he tends to give out decently expensive ones. Plus he sometimes gives out items I've never seen before/didn't know exist, which is pretty cool.
I've done sagittarius and wizard quests the most but also love doing item hunt if that counts? Sometimes Carl will surprise you with something rare too which is awesome.
🌷 🌷
Wizard & Alexander/Library for me - obviously wizard for tokens, and I like library quests because 1) they only ask for 1 item at a time, and 2) give rare item rewards that are good for selling
❄ [tot=iciness] ❄
Wizard / Sag - they help greatly!! Pete is a close second, though
:dmg:dark: :dmg:dark: :dmg:dark: :dmg:dark: :dmg:dark: :dmg:dark:<3 my av?:dmg:dark: :dmg:dark: :dmg:dark: :dmg:dark: :dmg:dark: :dmg:dark:
The Library; only ever one item so it's super quick to get them done and while the sp isn't usually much, the items are usually worth a good bit
[egg=Venusmores] [tp=Venusmores]
I think my favorite are the library quests!
[flower=AngelaJane]

My bias is with Shinwa, Quentin, Cinthia & Sagi
Why? Well Shinwa is my bias, I've developed a great love for her coming back- she's become one of my favorite NPCS haha!
The last three have been really spoiling me lately- I got FOUR morty cards out of Cinthia in one week, and Sagi & Quentin tend to give me the most money (Quentin I say because they have given me a LOT of amulets which has made their quests more than worth it)
It's interesting hearing everyone's different experiences with quest-givers. I have only gotten Morty cards off the Wizard, plus the tokens are super useful. I also like doing Quentin's quests for the mage amulets and cool items, and I think Quentin is probably my fave NPC too! I also like the library quests, sometimes Pete and Carl give you cool/useful stuff too. Cynthia never seems to give me much that's useful, and Maleria often asks for expensive stuff then doesn't give you a lot for it.
Dance with me? :)
I’m a fan of Saggy, Pete, and the Wizard. Cynthia is my least favorite for sure haha
I like most of them except quentin and maleria, i feel like theyre very hit or miss with the rewards, quentin especially
I honestly think all the quests that I can do are worth it. As of right now, I can't do Blue Building or Sarah.
What I do is I round up the items that the NPC is asking for to the closest thousand and add them up and then see if what they give is higher/lower. Quentin often asks for more expensive items but has a chance to give the mage amulets, which you can either sell for a high price or use as a stat booster for a pet. The rest of the quests usually give you more than they ask with Alexander, Pete, and Carl being the ones I notice giving lower than they ask for most frequently. However, they are also the ones giving items so I think it all balances out in the end.
Cursed will often give you more sP and items so they may be the most economic to add in and I have noticed a lot of people not mentioning those quests as ones they do daily.
TLDR: The quests often give you more value in items/sP than they ask for.